Fish: smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, pike
Mutton Lake is about 2 miles south of Orville along Star Lake Road. Access to the lake is limited as there are only two roads in. One service road goes down to the lake and the other heads south. It is a popular summer lake and the fishing is fair for bass and pike.
Our Lake Ontario list is growing and our goal is to strive to give the most comprehensive list available. If there is a particular lake we missed or you think deserves mention, please Contact Us. We'd love to hear from you.